Do you think that John Muir made an effective argument for saving the redwoods? Why or why not?

Answer:

The response is: Yes, John Muir effectively persuaded the public by appealing to the core concerns of society, prompting a positive reaction to preserving the redwoods.

Explanation:

In his plea to save the ancient redwoods, John Muir addressed multiple aspects: ethical values, religious beliefs, financial interests, artistic appreciation, health considerations, and national pride. Any of these appeals would have supported efforts to protect the trees.

The response is: Yes, John Muir effectively persuaded the public by appealing to the core concerns of society, prompting a positive reaction to preserving the redwoods.

John Muir presents a convincing case for protecting the redwoods. He uses logical evidence about their destruction, demonstrating his expertise through knowledge of the trees’ history. Additionally, he stirs readers’ emotions with powerful language to inspire them to help preserve the forests.