C- what was the reality of life for indentured Indians?
Child labor in factories and various industries was widespread.
This is the most accurate choice. The text suggests that the issue of child labor was significant enough to prompt the formation of a committee advocating for the rights of children. The other alternatives appear less plausible; if most business owners deemed child labor intolerable, a committee wouldn't have been necessary. Additionally, the passage doesn't assert that work was an unacceptable substitute for formal education. While it does mention that limiting the working hours for children would allow more time for school, it does not imply that work serves as an alternative to education. The rationale for selecting the first option contradicts the latter. It’s either prevalent or uncommon.
The text lacks a section that addresses opposing viewpoints or a formal conclusion.
There are several prominent writers who achieved recognition partly due to their laziness, yet there are also numerous examples of individuals whose hard work led to significant success across various fields. Michael Jordan is often celebrated as one of basketball's greatest, known for his fierce competitiveness and meticulous nature. In the realm of writing, Ray Bradbury famously produced a short story each week—an impressive output. Numerous successful authors have implemented strict writing goals and schedules. Therefore, while the notion of minimizing productivity may have been beneficial for some, a strong emphasis on it has proven favorable for many others.
I find my opposing argument quite persuasive. The original author's claims rely heavily on anecdotes. The argument would hold more weight if there was substantial evidence supporting it. However, the prevalence of anecdotal evidence that contradicts the main argument actually diminishes the author's case and bolsters my counterargument.
